White close button
Collaboration & Productivity
Pros and Cons of Google Collaborative Inbox
Hiver demo popup mobile

Hiver transforms Gmail into your team's collaborative workspace

Request a Demo

Table of contents

Hiver transforms Gmail into your team's collaborative workspace

Google Collaborative Inbox: Pros + Cons + Best Alternative

Jan 17, 2024
9 min read
Hiver HQ
Harsh Vardhan

Table of contents

There’s no doubt that email is a great platform for one-to-one business communication. But, have you used email for collaborative work?

Have you and your team used email to manage group inboxes such as [email protected] or [email protected]?

If yes, you’d have noticed that email can be a letdown in such scenarios. It lacks basic collaborative features such as assigning and tracking the progress of tasks.

Companies that are on Google Workspace turn to Google Collaborative Inbox when they hit this roadblock. Why? Because it’s a Google product and it’s built to help teams collaborate without leaving the Google ecosystem.

So, let’s dive in and find out more about the Google Collaborative Inbox – its pros, cons, and the best alternative to this platform.

Table of Contents

What is the Google Collaborative Inbox in Google Groups?

Google Groups Collaborative Inbox, as the name suggests, is a Google shared mailbox product to help teams distribute and track responsibility for emails that come to team inboxes like info@ or support@.

Why do we need a solution to manage group emails? Because Email was designed for personal use. When you want to distribute and share responsibility among team members, Gmail does not really do a great job at it. 

The only way you can share information or collaborate with others is through traditional features like CCs, BCCs, and FWDs — it’s no secret that they bloat inboxes and confuse people.

It hurts even more because we’re already struggling to manage emails every day.

Statistics about the use of email by professionals
A few stats about the use of email by professionals

As a result, a lot of Google Workspace (formerly G Suite) admins turn to the Google Collaborative Inbox because — it is made by Google. And they make awesome products.

Here are some ways Google’s Collaborative Inbox can be helpful to teams looking to collaborate over email.

The pros of using Google Collaborative Inbox

  • For starters, it’s free for all Google Workspace subscribers.
  • It takes less than five minutes to set up.
  • Members can assign conversations to other members or themselves.
  • Group owners can set different permission levels for team members to view, post and edit content.
  • Members can also categorize and label conversations by enabling the shared labels feature.
The best alternative to Google Collaborative InboxTry it for free

The cons of using Google Collaborative Inbox

Despite the benefits mentioned above, the Google Collaborative Inbox can be rather limiting for slightly larger teams – like Sales and Customer Support – wanting to achieve more than just collaboration.

1. Google Collaborative Inbox’s interface is complex to navigate

The Google Collaborative Inbox UI looks nothing like Gmail. It was not designed to work as an email client in the first place. It’s an entirely new interface that looks completely different from any other Google application.

Image showing Google Groups Collaborative Inbox UI Screenshot
Google Groups Collaborative Inbox UI

Your team will have to spend a lot of time just getting used to it. The UI is not intuitive like Gmail (I love Gmail. I am sure you do too!).

On top of that, they will have to keep swapping between their Gmail inbox and the Google Collaborative Inbox — there is a good chance a few emails will fall through the cracks.

Switching inboxes is also a big distraction for your team. And according to this study, the cost of distraction is huge:

The cost of distraction due to switching inboxes
The cost of distraction during work

2. There is no way to sync your emails seamlessly

When your team uses Google Collaborative inbox for a scenario like, say, customer support, ensuring that your emails are always synced and up-to-date is of utmost importance.

Unfortunately, this doesn’t always happen with the Google Collaborative Inbox. To maintain inbox sync, your team members would have to always remember to CC the Google Collaborative inbox email ID while replying to their customers.

If they skip doing this or even inadvertently forget to do this, theemail will not show up in the Collab inbox. And this could be a critical point of failure because your team members won’t even know of the existence of these emails.

This, of course, would lead to a loss of accountability and perhaps a barrage of unhappy customers.

Collaborate effortlessly and keep your teams productive

3. Internal communication becomes a hassle

No matter which team you are a part of – sales or customer service, seamless team collaboration is crucial to getting work done effectively.

Sometimes you’ll even have to collaborate with other departments for various reasons. However, for Google’s Collaborative Inbox users, neither internal nor cross-functional collaboration is easy. You mostly have to rely on long email threads, CCs, and forwards. Too many emails!

4. You will have a hard time finding the status of emails

Let’s assume you’re doing customer support from Gmail, and you start using the Google Collaborative Inbox.

An email arrives, and one of your teammates replies to the customer from their personal inbox. Unless that person has copied the group email address in the reply, you will not be aware of that. Nobody on the team will know that the email has been replied to.

Let’s say that person did remember to copy the group email address in the reply, but the customer does a ‘reply’ and not ‘reply all’ — it again comes to just one person.

You and the rest of the team will always be in the dark about the status of emails.

5. There’s enormous room for duplication of work

When you and your team don’t know if an email has been replied to, there is a good chance someone else might start working on it.

Imagine you’re running a sales team using the Collaborative Inbox in Google Workspace, and two sales executives end up replying to the same prospect. You’ve ruined your first impression right there. For all you know, you’d lose the client for being unprofessional.

The same applies to customer support teams. An email arrives, and two people start working on it at the same time. And then, both of them reply to the same customer — you’re essentially saying the same thing to the customer twice.

Even when you’ve assigned the email to an individual, the rest of the team would not know about it. To them, the email looks unattended unless they see a reply.

6. You will have to deal with a lot more emails

A good team tool should make it easy for people to communicate and collaborate. They should be able to exchange information without writing more emails.

But, inside a Google Collaborative Inbox, the only way to communicate with a teammate is by writing more emails.

Have a question to ask? Send an email, and you get a reply via email. Have a status update to ask? Send an email, and you again get a reply via email.

Basically, when you use the Google Collaborative Inbox, the only way you can exchange information with someone is by email — which unnecessarily clogs up everyone’s inboxes and slows down teamwork.

19 ways to manage emails

7. You’ll not be able to measure team performance

When you run your support or sales from the Google Collaborative Inbox, it is absolutely important that you know how well is the team dealing with emails.

Inside a Google Collaborative Inbox, if you’re looking to monitor team performance, all you’d know is the number of emails received and sent.

You have no way of knowing how your team deals with emails. For example, if you use the Google Collaborative Inbox to manage support, you will have no answers to (a) the average first response time, (b) the average time to close a ticket, or (c) who in your team needs more training.

Running support or sales without knowing how well your team manages emails is like driving a car with your eyes shut.

Well, the hard truth is that the Google Collaborative Inbox is completely unsuited for doing sales or support or anything that requires your team to collaborate.

And that is why we built Hiver.

How Hiver helps you achieve seamless team collaboration

Hiver has an answer to every Google Collaborative Inbox shortcoming. Allow me to run you through them.

1. Manage shared email accounts right from Gmail

When you use Hiver, you can create shared inboxes for your email accounts, such as support@, sales@, or info@.

And you can manage these shared inboxes from your Gmail inbox itself. You will no longer have to log into an alien interface like the Google Collaborative Inbox.

Hiver's shared inbox
You can use Hiver’s shared inboxes right from Gmail

You’d love this: When you use Hiver, there’s no limit to the number of users you can add to a shared inbox. Google, otherwise, does not allow more than 25 users to access a shared Gmail account.

2. Effortlessly delegate emails to your team (without forwarding)

Hiver lets you delegate emails to your teammates without having to forward them. All it takes is two clicks from the Gmail sidebar.

Your teammate can start replying to that email thread the moment you assign it to them. You do not even have to CC them.

Take an interactive tour of Hiver

3. Know email status in a jiffy

Every time you want to know what happened to an email you had assigned to someone, you will not have to send another email reminder.

Hiver tells you the status of every email in your shared mailbox: open, pending, or closed. It is again visible to everyone who is a part of the shared inbox.

Unlike the Collaborative Inbox, you will have access to replies your team sends even when you’re not copied on them.

4. Prevent ugly collisions and work duplication

When you assign an email to someone, everyone who is a part of that shared inbox can see that. The entire team will clearly know WHO is working on WHAT.

Inside a Hiver shared inbox, emails are classified into distinct groups: unassigned, mine, team, pending, and closed.

When you enter a shared inbox, the default view is ‘unassigned,’ which will only contain emails that nobody has started working on. You can go ahead and assign them to your team.

There is no room for confusion or duplication of work.

collision alerts for shared inbox
With Hiver’s Collision Alerts, you can avoid confusion or duplication of work

5. Make internal discussions easy

Hiver lets your team communicate with each other using Email Notes, which are like chat messages that appear right beside the email thread.

notes for shared inbox
Use Hiver’s Email Notes to give context to team members regarding a task

Using notes, you can communicate with anyone across your company. Notes come in handy for a host of things:

  • You want to broadcast a question to everyone in your team. Start the note with ‘@all’, and anyone in the group can now reply to your note.
  • You want to reach out to a specific person. Start the note with @name, and only that person will get notified. You can then exchange messages with that person like you would on personal chat.
  • You want to add some context or learning to the email which you think might come in handy in the future. Just write it down as a note, and it will stay alongside the email.

Basically, you and your team write fewer emails when you use Hiver’s Notes. You can completely eliminate internal emails if you use Notes the right way.

How to Use Google Groups for Effective Business Collaboration

6. Harness the power of reporting and analytics

When you run sales or customer service from Gmail, it is absolutely pertinent that you keep a keen eye on how well your team is dealing with emails.

Inside Hiver’s analytics, you have access to all vital customer support metrics (right inside your inbox).

Hiver Analytics
You can track your team’s performance with Hiver’s Analytics

And a lot more!

With Hiver, you also get the ability to:

  • Automate key actions like assigning emails and live chat messages based on preset rules.
  • Save combinations of email filters as views (such as all emails from Austria that Cynthia is yet to work on).
  • Save canned responses as email templates. Share them with your team to provide faster resolutions.
  • Collaborate on your email responses by sharing email drafts. Write a response, and have a colleague review it in real time.
  • Integrate apps like Slack, Asana, and Zapier and enhance productivity.

Learn more about Hiver

In a nutshell, Google Collaborative Inbox might not cut it if you’re using it in teams like sales and customer support. You need a tool that offers:

  • An intuitive user interface
  • Powerful collaboration features
  • Complete visibility into everyday workload
  • Insights into team performance

And that’s where Hiver’s got you covered. It comes with an easy setup, user-friendly collaboration features, and the power to scale as your business grows.

If you’re willing to give Hiver a shot and would like to learn how you can best manage your shared inboxes and drive efficiency, you can either:

Harsh is the content lead at Hiver. He's jocular, loves dogs, and is always up for a road trip. He also reads - when Netflix gets boring.

Deliver stellar customer support right from Gmail

* 7-day free trial | No credit card required
CTA image